Carl Alexander Simon: Romanticism, Arts, and Colonisation in Southern Chile (1848–1852)

On 19 February 1850, artist Carl Alexander Simon (1805 – 1852) went on board ship at the Port of Hamburg en route for Chile. There, driven by the idea of settling the south of that country and “civilizing” it, he wished to found a “new Germany” – a fatherland that in his fantasy was completely untouched by human hand, and which he called the “original country”. It was, he wished, to be free of the burden of Old Europe and to follow the motto he formulated in 1848: “If you cannot take the tyrants away from the people, so take the people away from the tyrants.”

In actual fact, Simon and other Germans started on arrival in Valdivia in June 1850 to lay the foundations for a colonization on the shores of Lake Llanquihue – on land that belonged to the Mapuche, one of Chile’s largest indigenous tribes, something that to this day leads to tensions among the settlers. Until his death in 1852, Simon busied himself with helping establish the colony and produced hundreds of drawings in which he recorded the life, the physiognomy, and the traditions of the Mapuche. In 1850, his magnum opus “Auswanderung und deutsch-nationale Kolonisation von Süd-Amerika mit besonderer Berücksichtigung des Freistaates Chile” was published, in which he vehemently advocated that Chile be occupied and settled by the Germans.

Carl Alexander Simon (1805-1852): “Die Kolonie Trinidad del Trumao” (The Trinidad del Trumao Colony), 1852, drawing on paper, 32 x 43 cm

Despite his active colonial involvement, the oeuvre of this Romantic all-round artist (he was not only a painter, but also a poet, writer, historian, critic, philosopher, politician, economist, and revolutionary) has to date not been studied in terms of its colonial traces. Art historian Dr. Miguel Gaete has set out to change this state of affairs by identifying the place Simon’s output takes in cultural and intellectual history in the context of German Romanticism and the efforts to colonize South America in the 19th century. What new insights can be gained from Simon’s hitherto unexplored oeuvre when it comes to the historical processes innate in the colonization of South Chile that German Romanticism so supported? How does it reflect the ethnocentric and nationalist ideas that were deeply rooted in the German society of the day and to what extent did these ideas inform how the German settlers treated the indigenous societies?

In this context, Dr. Gaete is conducting the very first examination of the linkages of text and images in Simon’s oeuvre in an effort to underscore how the two forms of artistic output influenced each other and thus spawned a narrative which interwove Romanticism, nationalism, and colonial discourses. He has chosen as his main written source material the treatise “Auswanderung und deutsch-nationale Kolonisation” which as part of his research will come out in a newly edited version and in a bilingual English/Spanish translation. The research will be accompanied by publishing individual aspects of the project in several lectures at international conferences and in at least two articles in specialist journals. Dr. Gaete wishes to bring all his research findings together in a monograph that focuses on Simon’s artistic views, the German colony in Chile, and the Mapuche communities.

Grant holder

Dr. Miguel Gaete, York

Support

The Gerda Henkel Foundation supports the project by granting a research scholarship and covering travel and material costs.

This project was documented in spring 2023.